Con: Should You Date for Marriage?

Artwork by Nina Suhrbier

Hear me children, for what I am about to say is true: you do not need to date with intent to marry. To feel as though you could spend the rest of your life with a person is wonderful, and there is nothing wrong with aspiring to that feeling. But to expect that feeling of the person you are with, the person you hope to be with, or whomever you end up catching feelings for next is unfair for all parties involved.

This is not an attack on marriage as an institution. Marriage is often a beautiful commitment, and one that I intend to make in the future. My point is simply that the judgement you make about your ability to marry another person is not one to make preemptively. Rather, it should be preceded by an intentional process: discovering what truly matters to you and finding deep compatibility between you and another. From this, you can jointly approach the question of lifelong commitment. 

To obstinately dismiss dating for something other than marriage means forgoing the bouts of passion and romance that may not lead to lifelong commitment but may teach you about yourself and the ways you interact with the world. Exploring intimate connections with different people opens your world to new perspectives and emotions in profound ways. Further, casual dating offers spontaneity and excitement from which many important lessons can be learned.

Still, dating without the intention of perpetuity can be terrifying. You thrust yourself into a world of volatility at a much greater risk of heartbreak and disappointment, as your expectations of the people you date change constantly. But breakups, though often and dreaded (rightfully so), are potentially beautiful moments for self-realization. While some breakups are more beautiful than others, the fear of an eventual heartbreak is not due reason to restrict the initial feelings from blossoming.

Oftentimes, people break up because one party “can’t envision a long-term future” with the other. This scripted language is often accepted without question, making it a convenient scapegoat for a relationship’s demise. It is worth giving pause to the tensions that gave rise to it, though, especially those that are hard to acknowledge or articulate. This is the moment for learning and self-understanding, where you can more accurately pinpoint what does and does not work for you. If we take marriage off of its pedestal in dating, perhaps we’ll more naturally come to these points of reflection. 

Common sense tells us that starting a relationship with the intention of marriage does not guarantee the relationship to succeed; more than this, it may be what dooms it from the start. The expectation sets forth a feeling of inevitability—the relationship is bound to hurdle toward some end. This is unfair to you—you may subconsciously undermine changes in your feelings. Meanwhile, it is unfair to your partner to project a level of commitment onto them that may not be true to their own feelings. Really, there are limitless possibilities for what commitment (or lack thereof) might look and feel like in a relationship. Leading with the standard of marriage might bar you from authentically discovering the type of commitment that best fits you and the particular person you’re with.

This leads me to the problem of our dating binary. Particularly in college, I have often heard and discussed two polar social pressures when it comes to dating. The first is of a culture that promotes casual sex and dating for social respect and clout. The foil is a pressure to settle down and commit to dating (this can sometimes arise as a response to engaging in casual sex/dating for an extended period of time). The truth is that no one should feel forced by some perceived culture into dating someone they do not deeply care for.

Eventually, many of us will end up marrying when we are ready for it. But this certainly does not mean it is incumbent upon us, as 18 to 22 year olds, to begin with such lofty expectations. I urge you not to embark on the dating world so goal-oriented toward marriage. I urge you to embark rather with open-mindedness and a hope for self discovery. Not only will these values nurture deep connections with yourself and the world around you, but they may just lead you to marriage—an authentic and durable one—in the end.

In sum, marriage isn’t breathing down your neck (it’s not going anywhere, the first recorded marriage was in Sumer, of all places); so don’t feel guilty exploring your feelings and relationships now—you may just thank yourself later.